David Moyes has earned trust, but TFG may soon face Everton’s biggest decision

David Moyes has done a solid job since returning to Everton. Few supporters would seriously argue otherwise. But his recent comments on talkSPORT have touched a nerve among a fanbase desperate to believe brighter days lie ahead under The Friedkin Group.

While the manager’s realism is understandable, many Evertonians were left wondering whether his vision for the club matches their own.

Has Moyes earned the right to be trusted?
When Moyes walked back through the door in January 2025, Everton needed stability and certainty.

The club had spent years firefighting. Relegation battles had become an annual event, financial concerns dominated every conversation, and Evertonians were tired of the constant instability as their neighbours prospered. Moyes inherited a difficult situation and, to be fair, quickly improved it.

Everton looked more organised. Results improved. The mood around the club lifted. In season 1.0 (second time around) he saved them from relegation. Simple as.

In many ways, he delivered exactly what was required. In season 2.0, he consolidated that stability. In the end, not much more than that – although seven games from the end of the campaign, it offered so much more – but a solid mid-table finish it was.

But this is why any discussion about his future should at least begin with an acknowledgement of what he has achieved. Everton are in a healthier position than they were before his arrival, and there was genuine value in having a manager who understands the demands of the football club and the expectations of its fans.

For all the criticism that followed his talkSPORT interview, there were plenty of fans who understood the point he was trying to make. Bournemouth and Brentford have been smarter, more consistent and, frankly, better run than Everton in recent years.

The problem was never really the comparison itself.

It was what it appeared to say about the club’s ambitions.

Evertonians dream bigger than survival and stability
Everton supporters have lived through enough false dawns to know success cannot happen overnight.

Most recognise that the club is not suddenly going to challenge the Premier League’s elite simply because there is new ownership and a bigger, beautiful, new stadium. Rebuilding takes time.

But there is also a belief among many fans that Everton should be aiming higher than simply becoming a more efficient version of their current selves.

That is why Moyes’ comments generated such a strong reaction. What’s wrong with thinking big and aiming for the stars?

For a fan now settling into said new home under ambitious owners, talk of matching Bournemouth and Brentford felt underwhelming. Evertonians want to hear about bettering those clubs in the short term, not modelling themselves on them.

That does not necessarily mean Moyes should be shown the door. Far from it.

The reality is that he has probably earned the opportunity to continue leading the project for now. There are limnited gains to be had from creating more upheaval when steady progress is being made… at least not two weeks before pre-season starts

Yet The Friedkin Group will eventually face a big decision.

Is Moyes the manager to rebuild Everton? The jury is very much out.

Is he the manager to take Everton to where supporters ultimately want the club to be? Hhmm.

For now, the answer may not matter.

But if Everton continue to move forward under TFG, this conversation will only grow louder.